News Summary
In a significant ruling, an Orange County judge has ordered Huntington Beach to eliminate youth-restricted sections in its library, following a lawsuit against the city’s book restrictions. The court mandates the reinstatement of all previously restricted books to promote compliance with the California Freedom to Read Act. The decision has been welcomed by library advocates, who criticized the restrictions as harmful to inclusivity and access to information. Despite the ruling, attorneys for Huntington Beach have challenged the court’s decision, raising questions about the city’s commitment to uphold public rights.
Huntington Beach Court Orders Reinstatement of Library Access Following Lawsuit Against Book Restrictions
An Orange County Superior Court judge has mandated that Huntington Beach eliminate a youth-restricted section on the fourth floor of the Central Library. The ruling, which was issued by Judge Lindsey Martinez, requires the city to return all books moved to this restricted section to their original locations, reversing restrictions that have been criticized by library advocates.
The court ruling comes as a direct outcome of a lawsuit filed in February by the plaintiffs, including advocacy group Alianza Translatinx, two teenagers, and former librarian Erin Spivey. They argued that the library’s policies undermined the 2024 California Freedom to Read Act. To ensure compliance, Judge Martinez signed a writ of mandate on October 7, formulated by Erin Spivey in conjunction with the ACLU of Southern California.
As part of the ruling, Huntington Beach must remove any signage that designates books as restricted and restore the existing teen section within the library. Furthermore, the city will not be allowed to require parental consent for minors to access library materials, effectively reinstating unrestricted access to all library content.
Erin Spivey characterized the ruling as a “complete defeat” for the City Council’s efforts to impose restrictions on library access. The writ mandates adherence to the California Freedom to Read Act, which stipulates that a publicly accessible development policy should be submitted to the State Librarian by January 1. The act also provides legal safeguards for library employees who oppose censorship practices.
In response to the court’s decision, attorneys representing Huntington Beach have filed an objection, claiming it overreaches and misrepresents the court’s intentions. They have reserved the right to appeal the ruling. The controversy began when Councilmember Gracey Van Der Mark proposed a policy change in 2023 that moved books such as “Gender Queer” from the young adult section to the adult section. Van Der Mark’s proposals were part of a broader effort to influence library materials through a challenge system that was deemed effective before the rise of political tensions regarding censorship.
The challenges led to significant resignations among library staff, who walked out in response to the city’s new policies, which many felt undermined the library’s mission of inclusivity and access to diverse viewpoints. Critics pointed out that the restrictive measures disproportionately impacted educational materials on gender identity and health, as well as classic literature—a sentiment echoed by the ACLU, which highlighted the detrimental effects of censorship on the library’s role as a place for knowledge and learning.
The plaintiffs’ arguments also underscored the overly broad definitions of “sexual content” that resulted in the removal of various titles. Notable examples of affected materials included books like “Everyone Poops” and “The Way We Work,” which were deemed inappropriate according to the newly enforced policies.
The recent controversies have raised questions about the Huntington Beach City Council’s commitment to uphold public rights and ensure constitutional access to information. A local measure, Measure A, passed by voters in June, eliminated a proposed library review board that was part of the City Council’s 2023 policy changes. This referendum also transferred authority over library materials to the city’s director of community and library services, Ashley Theel.
Huntington Beach continues to grapple with the implications of the court ruling and the challenges it poses to existing library policies. As the public awaits the city’s next moves, the focus remains on ensuring that libraries serve as inclusive spaces that uphold freedom of information for all community members.
Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic
HERE Resources
Huntington Beach City Council Passes Election Integrity Resolution
Westminster City Council Opposes VietRISE Amid Controversy
Newport Beach City Council Endorses Snug Harbor Surf Park Amid Controversy
Newport Beach Man Pleads Not Guilty in Triple Homicide
Walter Mosley to Speak at Huntington Beach Library Event
Nationwide ‘No Kings’ Gatherings for Peaceful Protest
Halloween Events in Orange County
Orange County Remembers 9/11 on 24th Anniversary
Huntington Beach Policy on Minors’ Book Access Overturned
Huntington Beach Judge Rules Against Restrictions on Minors’ Access to Books
Additional Resources
- NBC Los Angeles
- Wikipedia: Library Censorship
- LA Times
- Google Search: Huntington Beach library censorship
- CBS News
- Encyclopedia Britannica: Censorship
- OC Register
- Google News: Huntington Beach library access
- Courthouse News
- Google Scholar: Huntington Beach library lawsuit

Author: STAFF HERE COSTA MESA WRITER
COSTA MESA STAFF WRITER The COSTA MESA STAFF WRITER represents the experienced team at HERECostaMesa.com, your go-to source for actionable local news and information in Costa Mesa, Orange County, and beyond. Specializing in "news you can use," we cover essential topics like product reviews for personal and business needs, local business directories, politics, real estate trends, neighborhood insights, and state news affecting the area—with deep expertise drawn from years of dedicated reporting and strong community input, including local press releases and business updates. We deliver top reporting on high-value events such as the OC Fair, Concerts in the Park, and Fish Fry. Our coverage extends to key organizations like the Costa Mesa Chamber of Commerce and Boys & Girls Clubs of Central Orange Coast, plus leading businesses in retail, fashion, and technology that power the local economy such as Vans, Experian, and South Coast Plaza. As part of the broader HERE network, including HEREAnaheim.com, HEREBeverlyHills.com, HERECoronado.com, HEREHollywood.com, HEREHuntingtonBeach.com, HERELongBeach.com, HERELosAngeles.com, HEREMissionViejo.com, HERESanDiego.com, and HERESantaAna.com, we provide comprehensive, credible insights into California's dynamic landscape.