News Summary
The U.S. Department of Justice has initiated legal action against Orange County’s Registrar of Voters, Bob Page, for failing to provide adequate voter registration records related to non-citizens, potentially violating federal law. This lawsuit arose after a records request made by the DOJ, which was met with heavily redacted information from Page’s office. The case could have significant implications for voter registration practices and privacy regulations in Orange County.
Santa Ana, California – The U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) has initiated legal action against the Orange County Registrar of Voters, Bob Page, accusing him of failing to provide comprehensive voter registration records related to non-citizens. The lawsuit claims that Page has not maintained an accurate voter list, which is a violation of federal law as stipulated by the Help America Vote Act (HAVA), established in 2002.
The controversy began when the DOJ submitted an information request to the Orange County Registrar on June 2, seeking documents that would detail the cancellation of voter registrations due to non-citizen status dating back to January 2020. This request included a demand for specifics related to each cancellation, such as application copies, voting history, and correspondence with the county registrar.
While Page did provide some records, he heavily redacted personal and sensitive information, including driver’s license numbers, Social Security numbers, language preferences, race, and even signature images. The DOJ contends that these redactions hinder an accurate evaluation of whether the county is in compliance with election laws.
In defense, Page’s legal team argues that releasing sensitive personal information without a subpoena or court order is contrary to both California and federal laws. The dialogue between the Orange County office and the DOJ indicates an attempt to address these privacy concerns while still working towards fulfilling the DOJ’s request for information.
The California Secretary of State’s office clarified that state law imposes strict limitations on the release of personal identifiers, adding that they believe the DOJ was not open to collaborative solutions for addressing these restrictions. Page has clarified that confirming U.S. citizenship is mandatory for voter registration and that his office actively reviews registrations to ensure eligibility.
According to DOJ Assistant Attorney General Harmeet Dhillon, jurisdictions that refuse to disclose requested voter information are breaching federal election laws. The removal of non-citizens from voter rolls is deemed vital for maintaining accurate voter lists. The DOJ case is being led by prominent figures such as Harmeet Dhillon, Bill Essayli, a U.S. attorney, and Michael Gates, Deputy Assistant Attorney General, who previously expressed concerns over the potential for non-citizens to vote in Orange County.
This lawsuit follows reports and complaints indicating that non-citizens were receiving mail-in ballots, prompting the investigation by the DOJ. Voting by non-citizens is classified as a federal crime, according to Dhillon, who has emphasized the importance of holding local jurisdictions accountable for adherence to federal election standards.
County officials maintain that they are consistently working to remove ineligible voters and that they comply with existing state privacy regulations. There have been discussions regarding a potential confidentiality agreement between the county and the DOJ that would allow for the submission of confidential information. However, the lawsuit was filed shortly after these negotiations began.
Opinions among county supervisors appear divided. Some advocate for full transparency in responding to the DOJ’s requests, while others emphasize the legal restrictions surrounding the disclosure of certain information. Page’s office reported identifying only 17 ineligible voters out of a registered electorate of approximately 1.9 million, with 16 of those individuals self-reporting their ineligible status.
The DOJ’s approach to requesting state voter databases has raised concerns among election officials regarding potential misuse or political motivations behind the data request. As the legal proceedings unfold, the implications of this lawsuit could significantly impact how voter registration records are handled and managed in Orange County and potentially set a precedent for the regulations surrounding voter privacy and election integrity.
Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic
HERE Resources
DOJ Sues Orange County Registrar Over Voter Registration Issues
Additional Resources
- Orange County Register
- Wikipedia: Voting Rights in the United States
- Democracy Docket
- Google Search: Orange County voter registration
- KTLA
- Google Scholar: Justice Department lawsuit Orange County
- San Francisco Chronicle
- Encyclopedia Britannica: Voting
- Los Angeles Times
- Google News: DOJ lawsuit Orange County
